I have been a Zippo fan all my life, I'm now 65. I think the engraving on the lighter is great. But I did become bothered by the amount or lack of cotton or whatever the fiber is inside where the fuel goes because it was only half filled. I never saw this before, anyhow I took the filling out of an old Zippo I had and put in it and it's just fine now. One has to remember, even the best of them make mistakes. Other than that, I would have given d5 stars. Thanks for the lighter.